Astronomer Garth Illingworth, who helped build both the Hubble and James Webb Space Telescopes, says the first months of Webb data have already upended some long-held assumptions about the early universe. In an interview, Illingworth described how observations of distant galaxies are forcing researchers to revisit their models of how cosmic structures formed.
Illingworth, a professor at UC Santa Cruz and former deputy director of the Space Telescope Science Institute, has spent decades searching for the most distant galaxies. He was part of the team that developed Hubble and later helped conceive Webb in the 1980s, before Hubble even launched. At the time, institute director Riccardo Giacconi urged them to start planning the next big telescope, warning it would take a long time.
Webb's first images, released in July, were captured in an auditorium at the Space Telescope Science Institute—the same room where Illingworth attended the first Webb planning meeting 33 years ago. He said the data from just six sets of images exceeded anything he had seen in his career, and scientists will be analyzing that information for years.
Surprising Galaxy Masses
One of the most striking findings came within four days of Webb's data release. Two independent teams, including Illingworth's, submitted papers identifying several bright, distant galaxies similar to one previously discovered by Hubble—GN-z11, which dates to about 400 million years after the Big Bang. These new objects appear to be just as massive, and one is even farther away.
That contradicts expectations. Illingworth said theorists are now asking how such massive galaxies could have formed so quickly after the Big Bang. The galaxies might contain unusual stars that are bright but not heavy, or they could harbor rapidly growing black holes. "The universe can play games with you," he said, noting that more detailed observations are needed to determine what these galaxies really are.
Scientific Process in Action
Illingworth emphasized that such surprises are part of the scientific process. In the past, data came in slowly, and papers were often definitive. Now, with Webb's rapid output, researchers must be ready to revise their conclusions. "Being wrong isn't bad, it's part of the process," he said.
Looking ahead, Illingworth is eager to study exoplanets and star-forming regions like Carina and the Tarantula Nebula, which Webb has already imaged in stunning detail. He also pointed to the deep-field galaxy cluster image as a valuable tool for future research.
Beyond the science, Illingworth sees Webb as a unifying force. "We're living in a very divisive environment," he said, "and this interest cuts across political and other areas beautifully." He hopes the telescope will inspire common curiosity about our origins, from the formation of planets to the birth of galaxies.
As Webb continues to operate, its data will likely keep challenging assumptions. Illingworth and his colleagues are prepared for more surprises.





